Exodus 17: “Water from the Rock and Victory through Prayer”
1. The Journey Continues — and So Does Testing
“The people encamped… but there was no water for the people to drink.” (Ex 17:1)
The people have:
Passed through the sea
Drunk sweetened water
Eaten bread from heaven
And yet they now face thirst.
This teaches a sober Catholic truth:
Grace does not remove the need for trust; it deepens it.
St Augustine of Hippo writes:
“The redeemed are tested not to destroy them, but to teach them to depend on God.”
(Sermons)
2. The People Quarrel and Demand
“Give us water to drink.” (v. 2)
The word used here means accuse or put on trial.
The people are no longer asking — they are demanding.
This shows a dangerous shift:
From trust
To entitlement
Catholic faith distinguishes:
Prayer (humble asking)
From testing God (demanding proof)
3. Moses Names the Sin Clearly
“Why do you test the Lord?” (v. 2)
This is not honest confusion.
It is distrust after repeated grace.
Christ will later quote this verse in the desert:
“You shall not put the Lord your God to the test.”
4. The People Fear Death Again
“Why did you bring us up out of Egypt, to kill us?” (v. 3)
Fear returns quickly.
The Fathers note:
The memory of fear lasts longer than the memory of grace.
St Gregory of Nyssa explains:
“The soul newly freed still trembles at every hardship.”
(Life of Moses)
5. Moses Turns to God, Not Against the People
“What shall I do with this people?” (v. 4)
Moses does not abandon them.
He intercedes.
This is the heart of leadership in the Church:
The shepherd prays when the flock complains.
St John Chrysostom comments:
“The true shepherd does not strike the sheep, but pleads for them.”
(Homilies on Exodus)
6. God Commands Moses to Strike the Rock
“Take in your hand the staff… strike the rock.” (v. 5–6)
This is one of the most important symbolic actions in Scripture.
The staff:
Was used against Egypt
Was lifted at the sea
Now it is used to give life.
The rock is solid, lifeless, resistant.
7. Water Flows from the Rock
“Water came out of it, and the people drank.” (v. 6)
The Fathers are unanimous here:
The rock is Christ.
St Augustine of Hippo states plainly:
“The rock was Christ, struck so that living water might flow.”
(Tractates on John)
This points to:
Christ struck on the Cross
Water and blood flowing from His side
Baptism and the sacraments
Life comes not from human effort, but from Christ wounded for us.
8. The Place Is Named for Warning
“He called the name of the place Massah and Meribah.” (v. 7)
These names mean:
Testing
Quarrelling
God allows the memory of failure to remain as instruction.
Catholic faith does not erase history — it redeems it.
9. A New Threat Appears: Amalek
“Then Amalek came and fought with Israel.” (v. 8)
This is the first battle after redemption.
The Fathers saw Amalek as:
The enemy who attacks the weak
A symbol of temptation after conversion
Sin does not always attack openly.
It often strikes when we are tired.
10. Joshua Fights — Moses Prays
“Moses said to Joshua, ‘Choose for us men, and go out and fight.’” (v. 9)
Notice the balance:
Joshua fights
Moses prays
Catholic life always holds both:
Action
Prayer
But prayer is primary.
11. Moses Raises His Hands
“When Moses held up his hand, Israel prevailed.” (v. 11)
This is one of the clearest images of intercessory prayer in the Old Testament.
The Fathers unanimously saw here:
Moses forming the shape of the Cross
Victory flowing from prayer
St Justin Martyr writes:
“Moses’ outstretched hands prefigured the Cross, by which Christ conquered.”
(Dialogue with Trypho)
12. When the Hands Fall, the Enemy Advances
“When he lowered his hand, Amalek prevailed.” (v. 11)
This teaches a vital lesson:
Prayer is not decoration — it is decisive.
When prayer weakens, temptation strengthens.
13. Moses Cannot Pray Alone
“Aaron and Hur held up his hands.” (v. 12)
This is deeply Catholic.
No one sustains prayer alone.
The Church prays together:
Clergy
Laity
Community
St Bede the Venerable comments:
“Victory comes when prayer is shared and supported.”
(Commentary on Exodus)
14. The Enemy Is Defeated
“Joshua overwhelmed Amalek.” (v. 13)
The victory is complete — but it came through:
Prayer
Perseverance
Community
15. God Commands Remembrance
“Write this as a memorial.” (v. 14)
Spiritual victories must be remembered.
Forgetfulness invites defeat.
16. “The Lord Is My Banner”
“Moses built an altar and called the name of it, ‘The Lord is my banner.’” (v. 15)
A banner is:
Identity
Rallying point
Protection
The Church sees here:
Christ lifted on the Cross
The sign under which believers gather
St Augustine says:
“The Cross is the banner under which the faithful conquer.”
(Sermons)
Key Catholic Themes in Exodus 17
| Theme | Catholic Meaning |
| Thirst | Desire for grace |
| The Rock | Christ |
| Water | Sacramental life |
| Amalek | Temptation after conversion |
| Raised hands | Intercessory prayer |
| Community | Shared perseverance |
Christ at the Centre of Exodus 17
The Fathers are unanimous:
Rock → Christ
Water → grace and sacraments
Staff → the Cross
Raised hands → the Cross
Amalek → sin and temptation
Victory → prayer united to Christ
St Augustine summarises:
“From Christ struck flows life; by Christ lifted comes victory.”
(Sermons)
Spiritual Application
Do not be surprised by thirst after grace.
Bring demands back into prayer.
Drink deeply from Christ in the sacraments.
Expect temptation after conversion.
Support one another in prayer.
Closing Prayer
Lord God, giver of living water,
You quenched the thirst of Your people
and gave them victory through prayer.
Strike the Rock of our salvation,
that grace may flow into our lives.
Strengthen us in temptation,
unite us in prayer,
and raise our eyes to the Cross,
under which we conquer,
through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Amen.
St. Mary's, St. John Bosco and St. Edward's 